Saint Peters, Missouri

Two friends. Twenty years. One argument that never ended.

Backyards, tailgates, and long Saturdays in the smoke. Three sauces came out of all that — and we still can’t agree on which one is best.

See the sauces

✓ Small batch ✓ 12 oz bottles ✓ Ships from the USA ✓ Free shipping over $45

All three Double S BBQ Co. sauces — Sweet & Smoky, Stoten's Blazin, and Sieveking's Honey

The house line

Three sauces, two ways to buy more than one of them, and a few things to wear while you cook. Click anything to start an order — you'll get a reply from us with payment details, usually the same day.

Ingredient lists are supplied by our co-packer. Full allergen information is printed on every bottle — several of our sauces contain Worcestershire sauce, which commonly contains anchovy. If you cook for anyone with a fish, soy or mustard allergy, email us before you order and we’ll send you the exact statement for that batch.

How ordering works

We're two guys with a garage full of sauce, not a warehouse. So we keep it simple.

Send us your order

Pick what you want, tell us where to ship it. Takes about a minute and costs nothing yet.

We reply with the total

You'll hear back from Bryan with the final total including shipping, and how to pay. Usually same day, always within one business day.

We pack and ship

Once payment lands we box it up and get it moving, typically within one to two business days.

Our story

We've been friends for over twenty years, and we've spent most of them arguing about barbecue and anything that friends argue about! As our other friend Mitch shakes his head from a distance.

It was never really settled. Bryan’s side is thick and smooth and built on honey and apples — mild enough that it ends up on everything, chicken tenders and fries included. Shane’s is tangier and bolder, with enough on the back end that you notice it, and it turns out to be just as good on a steak as it is on a rib. Neither of us has moved much.

So we bottled both. Sieveking’s Honey is Bryan’s, Stoten’s Blazin is Shane’s, and Sweet & Smoky — mustard-forward and smoky, in the Southern Carolina Gold tradition — is the one we finally agreed on. Buy the trio and settle it yourself.

Double S is Sieveking and Stoten. Small batches, made for us and now made for you, out of Saint Peters, Missouri.

— Bryan & Shane